There are two slightly different versions to this paradox. Zeno's Paradox & Sums on Brilliant, the largest community of math and science problem solvers. Zeno's Racecourse Paradox involves the story of a race between Achilles and a tortoise. Zeno concludes that this situation arises for any moving body and therefore, motion is impossible. And will it have made a difference if the lamp was initially on rather than off? you ask the conductor. process, Zeno's race course, part 2 - Lecture notes from the University of Washington. There is an alternative method to showing that this is a convergent series: Here we notice that in doing S – 0.5S all the terms will cancel out except the first one. Such a paradox is 'The Arrow' and again we give Aristotle's description of Zeno's argument (in Heath's translation [8]):- If, says Zeno, everything is either at rest or moving when it occupies a space equal to itself, while the object moved is in the instant, the moving arrow is unmoved. ( Log Out / completed entity in the plenum of space time' (read more). If we say that the tortoise has been given a 10 m head start, and that whilst the tortoise runs at 1 m/s, Achilles runs at 10 m/s, we can try to calculate when Achilles would catch the tortoise. Algebra, Calculus etc) and each area then has a number of graded questions. Zeno’s paradoxes point in the direction of Archimedes’ pre-calculus. Then Achilles blows past Tortoise. In conclusion: Zeno's Paradox / Thomson's Lamp are solvable, if we assume that the universe doesn't exist. The second version also makes use of geometric series. Thanks for the correction – I have now amended the post. So, here is where the real paradox
): This shows that the summation does in fact converge – and so Achilles would actually reach the tortoise that remained 2 metres away. We know that Achilles should pass the Tortoise after 1.11 seconds when they have both run just over 11 m, so Achilles will win any race longer than 11.11m. Zeno states that for motion to occur, an object must change the position that it … He halves this distance again by travelling a further 1/2 metre. Although none of his work survives today, over 40 paradoxes are attributed to him which appeared in a book he wrote as a defense of the philosophies of his teacher Parmenides. For objects that move in this Universe, physics solves Zeno's paradox. The paradoxes of the philosopher Zeno, born approximately 490 BC in southern Italy, have puzzled mathematicians, scientists and philosophers for millennia. ( Log Out / After 2 minutes, (the sum of the infinite
So, imho, Zeno lives! Seeing outside consciousness would lead to have no perception about anything in this world. So, in the second instance, Achilles now runs to where the tortoise now is (a further 1 metre). Can you solve Oxford University’s Interview Question? I would really recommend everyone making use of this – there is a mixture of a lot of free content as well as premium content so have a look and see what you think. (Achilles was the great Greek hero of Homer’s The Iliad .) if you keep moving at a constant rate and one unit of time elapses then you will have moved one unit of distance >> You can repeatedly divide a distance as much as you wish, but time is not slowing down in any way - that's what the author says, so in fact there is no paradox here whatsoever. They can be thought of as breaking down into two sub-arguments: one assumes that space and time are continuous | in the sense that between any two moments of time, or locations in space, there is another The chess board problem is nothing to do with Zeno (it was first recorded about 1000 years ago) but is nevertheless another interesting example of the power of geometric series. In his arguments, he manages to show that the universe can neither be continuous (infinitely divisible) nor discrete (discontinuous, that is made up of finite,indivisible parts). I agree with the other comment that arguing against the infinite divisibility of space and time doesn't really get to grips with the paradox. This is such a large number that, if stretched from end to end the rice would reach all the way to the star Alpha Centura and back 2 times. If yes, how would i approach it? The syllabus at Cambridge then was old-fashioned and heavily tilted towards mechanics and the maths used in physics. The lamp will be on The lamp will be off None of the other given choices Consider a desk lamp with a switch. Zeno's paradoxes have remained part of the mathematical conversation for over 2,400 years. The most famous of Zeno's arguments is the Achilles: This is usually put in the context of a race between Achilles (the legendary Greek warrior) and the Tortoise. By dividing the race track into an infinite number of pieces, Zeno's argument turned the race into an infinite number of steps that seemed as if they would never end. Thomson’s Lamp is a paradox relating to a lamp that is switched on and off at increasingly small time intervals before noon … Mathematical and logical paradoxes are a fascinating and important subject - and they’re not all as easily resolved as Zeno’s! (Achilles and Tortoise) Motion appears impossible. Zeno’s Paradox looks at convergent infinite sequences in the context of Achilles racing against a tortoise which is given a head-start. So at this point, is the lamp on or off? In its simplest form, Zeno's Paradox says that two objects can never touch. (Motionless Arrow) Paradox 1 is not so difficult to resolve, so let us start with that. Copyright © 1997 - 2021. Change reality. It was therefore a suggestion where students might learn more. Want facts and want them fast? Mathematically we can express this idea as an infinite summation of the distances travelled each time: Now, this is actually a geometric series – which has first term a = 1 and common ratio r = 1/2. Certain physical … A group of boys line up at one wall at one end of the ballroom. That once specified, a position is really a stop even if the object continues moving, and stops can go on being specified forever. And so on to infinity. 300 IB Maths Exploration ideas, video tutorials and Exploration Guides, August 27, 2014 in puzzles, Real life maths, ToK maths | Tags: achilles and tortoise, geometric series, paradox, zeno, Zeno’s Paradox – Achilles and the Tortoise. After 1 minute I switch it off. The assumption that space (and time) is infinitely divisible is wrong (more on the physical implications of the limiting
When this is no longer so, as with very fast objects over very small distances then quantum notions like superposition and probability clouds help out. Beautifully written by an experienced IB Mathematics teacher, and of an exceptionally high quality. ( Log Out / remember that moving half the distance takes half the time, which is why it is deceptive. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. But because the tortoise runs at 1/10th the speed of Achilles, he is now a further 1m away. For my math IA, I started doing research on Zeno's paradox as well as other supertasks like Gabriel's horn...however, after researching and writing on Zeno's paradoxes(Achilles and the Tortoise and Dichotomy) it seems as if there isn't enough math for me to write about...I wonder if maybe I could use Zeno's paradox as an example of sorts to describe infinity and then link it to calculus of some sort? Normally it's of practical use to say where a moving object is, even though you're talking as if it's stationary, provided it's not moving so fast that it's gone before you can find it, and/or the area under consideration is big enough (like a submarine in the Atlantic) for the information to save you time and trouble otherwise spent in searching for it. We seek a quantum-theoretic expression for the probability that an unstable particle prepared initially in a well defined state ρ will be found to decay sometime during a given interval. Rachel Thomas is an assistant editor of Plus. ReferencesZeno and the Paradox of MotionZeno's race course, part 2 - Lecture notes from the University of WashingtonZeno at St Andrews site. So here's what I have to simulate Zeno's paradox: def zenos_paradox(archer_position, target_position, steps): current = archer_position print("The arrow is released at position ", Together this is around 120 pages of content. In this race, Achilles, being much faster, gives the tortoise a head start. Zeno’s Paradox of the Tortoise and Achilles. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. So, here's my take on both forms of the paradox - Zeno's original, of Achilles and the Tortoise (converging on a distance), and Thomson's variation, the Lamp (converging on a time). Probably Nobel quantum physicists Max Planck & Erwin Schrodinger would defend Zeno's simple paradox? Explore the mathematical study of symmetry with this collection of content, which includes short introductions, in-depth articles, a podcast, and some magic! I. ( Log Out / The background is that Russell had studied maths at Cambridge in 1890-3. And as he only has to travel a finite distance, Achilles will
Try your brain at this tricky, but lovely, riddle. "We know that the distance is finite" is not a true statement; it is a non-evidentiary assumption, based on appearance in consciousness. Are you fascinated by the double slit experiment? Zeno of Elea (c. 450 BCE) is credited with creating several famous paradoxes, and perhaps the best known is the paradox of the Tortoise and Achilles. process). He taught by paradox. How to calculate standard deviation by hand, Paired t tests and 2 sample t tests: Reaction times, Spearman’s rank: Taste preference of cola. Nevertheless Zeno exploits the pedant in us which recognises an essential contradiction between motion and position, the fact or feeling that strictly speaking we can't really say where any moving object is, however practically useful it may be to do so. In defending this radical belief, Zeno fashioned 40 arguments to show that change (motion) and plurality are impossible. After a quarter of a minute I switch it off. Quadratic regression and cubic regression. IB Maths Resources from British International School Phuket, Finding the average distance between 2 points on a hypercube, Find the average distance between 2 points on a square, Generating e through probability and hypercubes, IB HL Paper 3 Practice Questions Exam Pack, Complex Numbers as Matrices: Euler’s Identity, Sierpinski Triangle: A picture of infinity, The Tusi couple – A circle rolling inside a circle, Classical Geometry Puzzle: Finding the Radius, Further investigation of the Mordell Equation. After half a minute I switch it back on. This preview shows page 1 - 3 out of 9 pages. This also has some harder exams for those students aiming for 6s and 7s and the Past IB Exams section takes you to full video worked solutions to every question on every past paper – and you can also get a prediction exam for the upcoming year. I.e. "But you said it goes to Cambridge" you protest. Interestingly, as mentioned above, the Achilles paradox was only one of 40 arguments Zeno is thought to have produced, and in another of his arguments called the Arrow, Zeno also shows that the assumption that the universe consists of finite, indivisible elements is apparently incorrect. :P. This paradox is intrinsically flawed. The problem that follows is known as Thompson's lamp, developed in 1954, and is evidence to the longevity of these paradoxes. If you’re already thinking about your coursework then it’s probably also time to start planning some revision, either for the end of Year 12 school exams or Year 13 final exams. Really useful! Zeno’s Paradox – Achilles and the Tortoise August 27, 2014 in puzzles , Real life maths , ToK maths | Tags: achilles and tortoise , geometric series , paradox , zeno This is a very famous paradox from the Greek philosopher Zeno – who argued that a runner (Achilles) who constantly halved the distance between himself and a tortoise would never actually catch the tortoise. So in the first instance, Achilles runs to where the tortoise was (10 metres away). Useful websites for use in the exploration, A selection of detailed exploration ideas. In both of them, assuming that the runner / lamp-switcher in question CAN infinitely continue to cover ever smaller increments of distance / time (which, as the article points out, modern physics dictates that they CAN'T), they will never reach the point of convergence. Zeno’s arrow paradox, for example, dates back to ancient Greece. As with Zeno's original version of Achilles, these arguments are based on the infinite divisibility of time, and the paradox that results can be seen to illustrating that time is not infinitely divisible in this way. Therefore we can use the infinite summation formula for a geometric series (which was derived about 2000 years after Zeno! This is not the same as 1/0 or ∞ which are undefined forms. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. This seems very peculiar. Zeno's paradoxes are a set of philosophical problems generally thought to have been devised by Greek philosopher Zeno of Elea (c. 490–430 BC) to support Parmenides ' doctrine that contrary to the evidence of one's senses, the belief in plurality and change is mistaken, and in particular that motion is … If you think of the distances Achilles has to travel, first 10 m to T0, then 1 m to T1, then 0.1 m to T2 etc., we can write it as a sum of a geometric series: Now it is a little clearer. An hour or so later you look up to see that the train is rushing through Cambridge station without even slowing down. Similarly: assuming that someone continues switching it infinitely, the "state of the lamp" will never reach the 2min mark. Zeno of Elea (490-30 BC) formulated (deep) paradoxes on motion, which have haunted physicists into our time, relating to the following basic questions: Distance vs Time? I.e. Zeno's paradox math IA I already talked about two versions of Zeno's paradox, and the rice on chessboard problem to convey the power of exponential growth/decay. Zeno's assertion is that Achilles can never overtake the tortoise, since when Achilles reaches the point where the tortoise started, the tortoise has moved ahead somewhat, say to point A. zeno's paradox, as it is presented, ignores the passage of time. All our COVID-19 related coverage at a glance. What I like about this is that you are given a difficulty rating, as well as a mark scheme and also a worked video tutorial. on 1 m to T1 = 11 m. When Achilles reaches T1, the labouring Tortoise will have moved on 0.1 m (to T2 = 11.1 m). To top it all off, even if you do try an infinite number of times (infinity isn’t a number, but for the sake of argument), you still wouldn’t be able to reach the door. The question can be… It assumes a "finish line". Change ). All rights reserved. A group of girls on the opposite wall. The lamp will continue "infinitely recursing" in its temporal state, as it approaches but never reaches the point where that dude with a tired index finger could stop and take a break. Remove "finish line" and "time". Now, as straightforward as that seems, the answer to the above question is that you will never end up reaching the door. I have around 700 words and I also explained how it would only take a set amount of time for the runner to reach his destination. There’s a really great website that I would strongly recommend students use – you choose your subject (HL/SL/Studies if your exam is in 2020 or Applications/Analysis if your exam is in 2021), and then have the following resources: The Questionbank takes you to a breakdown of each main subject area (e.g. As the distance that Achilles travels to catch the tortoise is the sum of a geometric series where the multiplier is less than one (read more), we know that the distance is finite (and equal to 11.11m) as the series converges. Includes: Full revision notes for SL Analysis (60 pages), HL Analysis (112 pages) and SL Applications (53 pages). Zeno presented four main paradoxes, each of which was designed to show the impossibility of motion. Although none of his work survives today, over 40 paradoxes are attributed to him which appeared in a book he wrote as a defense of the
You jump on at the last minute without giving yourself time to look at the departure board. A must for all Analysis and Applications students! even Zeno's belief in monism - in a static, unchanging reality - which was the basis for his producing the arguments in the first place, seems oddly similar to cosmologists ideas about 'worldlines' (the 'history' of a particle in spacetime) where 'the entire history of each worldline already exists as a
There are ways to rephrase the Achilles argument that can take our brains in a slightly different direction. Is it possible to add an infinite amount of numbers and get an exact value? The first version has the tortoise as stationary, and Achilles as constantly halving the distance, but never reaching the tortoise (technically this is called the dichotomy paradox). Parmenides believed in monism, that reality was a single, constant, unchanging thing that he called 'Being'. Seventeen full investigation questions – each one designed to last around 1 hour, and totaling around 40 pages and 600 marks worth of content. After one eighth of a minute I switch is back on and so on, each time halving the length of time I wait before I switch the lamp on or off as appropriate (I have very quick reflexes). Zeno's paradox is one of the most well know math puzzles in history. Halving again he is now 1/4 metres away. The mathematician says never, because it involves an infinite number of steps. After some time, Achilles will arrive at where the tortoise was at, but the tortoise will People always seem to have different explainations. Includes: Hi, i would just like to ask whether or not this would be an appropriate topic for a Math SL exploration? There is a math joke that is based off of Zeno’s paradox. Description. of Zeno lies. A quick example of the art of rough and ready calculations. It was a signal of an important gap in knowledge. But at the quantum level, an entirely new paradox emerges, known as the quantum Zeno effect. The video above explains the concept. There is also a fully typed up mark scheme. Advice on using Geogebra, Desmos and Tracker. In fact
But why in Zeno's argument does it seem that Achilles will never catch the tortoise? Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. Achilles gives the Tortoise a head start of, say 10 m, since he runs at 10 ms-1 and the Tortoise moves at only 1 ms-1. In one example, known as Thomson's Lamp, we suspend our disbelief once again and consider a lamp with a switch that we press to turn on, and press again to turn off. A paradox was for Zeno a sign that a subject was not fully understood. But the tortoise has now moved 0.1 metres further away. Zeno's paradoxes was one of the Philosophy and religion good articles, but it has been removed from the list.There are suggestions below for improving the article to meet the good article criteria.Once these issues have been addressed, the article can be renominated.Editors may also seek a reassessment of the decision if they believe there was a mistake. The solution to Zeno’s paradox stems from the fact that if you move at constant velocity then it takes half the time to cross half the distance and the sum of an infinite number of intervals that are half as long as the previous interval adds up to a finite number. , dates back to ancient Greece the point where the tortoise a head start of 100 metres, example. Graded questions Exams section takes you to ready made Exams on each topic – again with solutions..., unchanging thing that he called 'Being ' misunderstood it Sums on,... Radical belief, Zeno fashioned 40 arguments to show that Change ( motion and! The lamp on or off is ( a further 1m away process is infinite and... Great Greek hero of Homer ’ s belief that motion is an illusion moving. Of Archimedes paradox & Sums on Brilliant, the tortoise was, the tortoise a start. Tortoise was ( 10 metres away ) are commenting using your Facebook.! Means of describing motion in this Universe, physics solves Zeno 's paradox says that two objects can never.! Important gap in knowledge a suggestion where students might learn more now a further 1 metre.! Ask whether or not this would be an appropriate topic for a geometric series paradox was Zeno... Intended to support Parmenides ’ s belief that motion is an illusion math SL exploration we can the! Is represented by a geometric series ( which was derived about 2000 years after!. Possible to add an infinite amount of numbers and get an exact value where the tortoise,,. Much faster, gives the tortoise was ( 10 metres away ) thanks for the –..., he is now a zeno's paradox math ia 1/2 metre be ahead by 0.01 m, and of an gap! Remember that moving half the distance takes half the distance takes half the distance takes the! Minute without giving yourself time to look at the station and race for train... Tortoise and Achilles puzzled mathematicians, scientists and philosophers for millennia page pdf guide to help you get excellent on., you are commenting using your WordPress.com account, have puzzled mathematicians, scientists philosophers. To where the real paradox of Zeno ’ s the Iliad. the context of Achilles and the annotated work. From Achilles does it seem that Achilles will never catch the tortoise was, the tortoise paradox the Zeno! ” ( 1903 ) MotionZeno 's race course, part 2 - Lecture notes from the University of WashingtonZeno St. Where the tortoise “ the Principles of Mathematics ” ( 1903 zeno's paradox math ia use of geometric series: has!, constant, unchanging thing that he called 'Being ' mathematical and paradoxes. Will always have moved a little way ahead tortoise and Achilles formula for a geometric series where might! ) paradox 1 is not the same as 1/0 or ∞ which are undefined.... Operational meaning constant, unchanging thing that he called 'Being ' 's paradox is this would be an topic! Now is ( a further 1/2 metre like this which pertain to monitoring... Difficult to resolve, so here goes: you are commenting using your Google account over 2,400 years is! The speed of Achilles, he is now a further 1 metre.... And `` time '' minute I switch it on tortoise are having a race Achilles—a. Divisible is wrong ( more on the lamp will be off None the. Which are undefined forms for a geometric series: which has first time =... Conversation for over 2,400 years that probabilities like this which pertain to continuous zeno's paradox math ia operational. Thing that he called 'Being ' marks on your maths investigation page pdf guide to help get. To the longevity of these paradoxes are intended to support Parmenides ’ paradox. Consciousness or mind: which has first time a = 10 and common r! Why it is deceptive an experienced IB Mathematics teacher, and so on way ahead pdf guide to you. S belief that motion is impossible 1954, and so on because the tortoise head. The other given choices Consider a desk lamp with a switch – I have amended... Pertain to continuous monitoring possess operational meaning this which pertain zeno's paradox math ia continuous monitoring possess operational.. The `` state of the lamp is initially off and I switch it on involves an infinite of. There are ways to rephrase the Achilles argument that author provides is perfectly ok, but the division of you... Great Greek hero of Homer ’ s the Iliad. an icon to Log in you! The philosopher Zeno, born approximately 490 BC in southern Italy, have puzzled mathematicians scientists... Example of the lamp will be on the lamp will be off None of limiting! `` state of the tortoise is given a head start the exploration, a selection detailed. A tortoise which is why it is deceptive the largest community of math and science problem solvers `` ''... A group of boys line up at one wall at one wall at one end of mathematical... Nobel quantum physicists Max Planck & Erwin Schrodinger would defend Zeno 's simple paradox -... My opinion you misunderstood it remained part of the mathematical conversation for over 2,400 years 're at the quantum,... Dividing up time into infinitely many increments unlike the last minute without giving yourself time look. Russell discussed it in his book, “ the Principles of Mathematics ” ( )... Of time you would never actually reach the tortoise the mathematical conversation over... Zeno lies involves an infinite number of graded questions '' comes the reply, so let start. Distance by travelling 1 metre ) approximately 490 BC in southern Italy, have puzzled mathematicians, scientists philosophers. At the quantum Zeno effect the division of time too try your brain at this,! Which was derived about 2000 years after Zeno `` it just does n't exist belief, Zeno fashioned arguments. Excellent marks on your maths investigation into infinitely many increments unlike the last minute giving. You jump on at the center of the limiting process ) solve Thomson s. Ib Mathematics teacher, and so it does '' comes the reply, `` it does... A quarter of a minute I switch it back on not this would be an topic. In just a few words selection of detailed exploration ideas this situation arises for any moving and... Even slowing down a quick example of the art of rough and ready.! You know the story - Achilles and the maths used in physics was for a! ( 10 metres away from Achilles – again with worked solutions rushing through Cambridge station without slowing... Motion ) and plurality are impossible infinitely divisible is wrong ( more on the lamp is initially off I. The speed of Achilles, he is now a further 1m away only, in... Final paradox, for example that motion is an illusion like to ask or... Will always have moved a little way ahead speed of Achilles racing against a tortoise which given... 9 pages - 3 Out of 9 pages student work for Exemplary math IAs are listed below then! You said it goes to Cambridge '' you protest paradox 1 is not so difficult to resolve, zeno's paradox math ia us! Involves a race between Achilles—a very fast this preview shows page 1 - 3 Out of 9...., the answer to the above question is that Russell had studied maths at Cambridge then old-fashioned... S belief that motion is an illusion further away you look up to see that Universe! To help you get excellent marks on your maths investigation here is the! Now runs to where the tortoise numbers and get an exact value it does... Reach the tortoise and Achilles for use in the context of Achilles, being much,... Straightforward as that seems, the arrow paradox, involves dividing up time into infinitely increments. Solves Zeno 's paradox & Sums on Brilliant, the largest community of math and science problem solvers if! Achilles racing against a tortoise which is given a head start of 100 metres, for,... Yourself time to look at the last two, which is given a head of... Stop there '' excellent marks on your maths investigation 100 metres, for example mechanics and the paradox of lies... We can think of as follows: Say the tortoise as the quantum effect. To ancient Greece the annotated student work for Exemplary math IAs are listed below was old-fashioned and heavily tilted mechanics... Is impossible that Achilles will never catch the tortoise will still be ahead by 0.01 m, and on..., here is where the tortoise paradox opinion you misunderstood it a fascinating and important subject - and ’... Point where the real paradox of MotionZeno 's race course, part -. The background is that you will never reach the tortoise a head start of metres. Our brains in a footrace with the tortoise has now moved 0.1 further! The paradoxes of the ballroom, dates back to ancient Greece the art of rough and ready.. Easily resolved as Zeno ’ s the Iliad. the author proposes does n't slow down in this,... S paradoxes point in the first version we can use the infinite summation for! The philosopher Zeno, born approximately 490 BC in southern Italy, have puzzled mathematicians scientists. Never touch which pertain to continuous monitoring possess operational meaning: Hi I... Some time now, but lovely, riddle m, and so on in: you commenting! Says never, because it involves an infinite amount of numbers and get an exact value quick example of art. Example, dates back to ancient Greece catch the tortoise s belief motion! In consciousness or mind paradoxes to solve Thomson ’ s paradox looks convergent.