She and her prose are whip smart. From London to New York, love to death, fathers to sons, Alex tries to discover how a piece of paper can bring him closer to his heart's desire. But, it's the ending, which in both her more lauded first and third novels she was criticized for over stage-managing, where this novel shines, for though the plot comes to a pleasing conclusion, the characters are all left in very recognizable places of transition, between my generation's extended adolescence and adulthood, a threshold where we must look at faith, love and the relationships in our lives and realize that no amount of pop culture savvy can save us. I read the entire thing hoping that at some point it'd turn the corner and pick up the pace, but no, it just basically ground itself out into a completely anti-climactic ending. It pains me to say it, as Smith’s other four novels are all absolute delights, but unfortunately I found this one very tedious - But you can all rest assured that I recommend White Teeth, Swing Time, On Beauty and NW heartily! It's more mature in some ways than White Teeth, darker, and I would imagine in many ways a reflection on Smith's part on the fame. The way her brain works is incredible: how she settled on a story about a Chinese-Jewish autograph connoisseur is mind boggling, but it made for a story that was at times funny, tender, and introspective. The Autograph Man is a deeply funny existential tour around the hollow trappings of modernity: celebrity, cinema, and the ugly triumph of symbol over experience. I much preferred the second part to the first but not enough to say that I would read it again or recommend it. The Autograph Man, published in 2002, is the second novel by Zadie Smith. But Alex's life is a shambles. The plot and the message being delivered seemed to. [1] It follows the progress of a Jewish-Chinese Londoner named Alex-Li Tandem, who buys and sells autographs for a living and is obsessed with celebrities. Autograph Man, making a living buying and selling famous names, obsessively pursuing the very rare autograph of 1940s Hollywood movie star, Kitty Alexander. How did Smith know to wrap up the humour of philography, the elusiveness of fame, the over-the-top sanctity of religious belief, and the ongoing effort to reconcile with death all in one go? “She hopes for nothing except fine weather and a resolution. 9 Books that Goodreads Editors Highly Recommend. One of those serendipitous moments for me: looking for another of Zadie Smith's books, What started out as a promising read quickly turned into a...really crappy one. But it's a very short section in comparison to the whole novel. Guardiola had no issue with assistant Octavian Sovre’s conduct There are, of course, minor abuses now and then. While it demonstrates Smith's tongue-in-cheek humour, it is incredibly slow to start, and the characters are such superficial creations, that it is often difficult to empathise with them. See guidelines for writing about novels. Her characters live. Its tone, especially in the first half, is somber and claustrophobic, as the reader follows the protagonist, Alex Li-Tandem, through the aftermath of a drug-induced hangover as he prepares for the anniversary of his father's death. The Autograph Lyrics: Just turn the beat down just a little bit / Hey, yeah / They say anything's possible / You gotta dream like you never seen obstacles / … Smith's wonderful ability to capture speech in her prose is … The Autograph Man has been described as "wonderfully funny" and "witty". I'd delayed reading this book for many years because of the mediocre reviews but there it was: a lone English novel, in a Spanish book shop, so I decided to take the plunge. If so, you're not alone. ”, “She loved you in the morning because the day was new.”, Orange Prize Nominee for Fiction Shortlist (2003), Bollinger Everyman Wodehouse Prize Nominee for Comic Fiction (2003), Jewish Quarterly-Wingate Prize for Fiction (2003). I did not check reviews before reading this, but I could not help noticing the VERY low average rating - a 3.16. His business is to hunt for names on paper, collect them, sell them, and occasionally fake them—all to give the people what they want: a little piece of Fame. Reviewed in the United States on November 14, 2005 Reading the first book of "The Autograph Man" is most of the time very annoying. You can help Wikipedia by expanding it. It seems absurd in theory, but I seem to have an inimitable connection with the product of her many hours of brilliance. Book reviewing is ordinarily an honorable process, like say, college admissions, in which righteous judgment flows from disinterested appraisal of a subject's merit. (The only character I found a bit underdeveloped was Esther, but this may have been intentional as we only see her through Alex's thoughts and what others say to him for most of the book. It also suggests that ordinary people's release from traditions that offer no inclusion might be liberation. Something is lost with the lack of any generational span. Has anyone read The Autograph Man and what do you think? At the conclusion, he did mention that certain sentences displayed brilliance, but these were not enough to save the novel. Once again I felt this with The Autograph Man. An autograph man is, just as it sounds, someone who deals in autographs of the famous and infamous. by Vintage. I let this book's bad reviews sway me and didn't read it until now. While there are certainly many attempts at humour, I did not find the usually drunken or doped meanderings of Alex Li Tandem appealing to my sense of humour. I am so glad that this is the second zadie smith book that I have read, for rest assured, if it had been the first it would have been the only. An unmatched feeling (exclusive to the luxury of reading for pleasure) constantly arises: I read, I stare at a household object or tree and repeat the gifted string of words, thinking, how in the world did anyone know to write this? She wants to end properly, like a good sentence. The Autograph Man Zadie Smith Review by Arlene McKanic. I can certainly understand the disappointment for those critics and fans who awaited its arrival after her stunning debut, "White Teeth." There is one brief section I did like towards the beginning of the novel, narrated from the point of view of the Alex's father. The Autograph Man is a deeply funny, existential tour around the hollow things of modernity - celebrity, cinema, and the ugly triumph of symbol over experience. Unlike seemingly everybody else, I didn't think, I enjoyed Smith's writing style far more than I enjoyed the plot (which promised some things but delivered others) or the characters (who are neatly drawn, but on paper that is very thin indeed); but even the sometimes whimsical, sometimes nervy, sometimes delightful turns of her prose weren't enough to save The Autograph Man from being something of a disappointment. I thought it was great and I'm ashamed of myself. Alex's quest to find Kitty in New York with the notorious Honey did revive my interest in the story but the return to London and concluding events failed to sustain it. By Nick Britten 09 December 2006 • 00:01 am . I have struggled with Zadie Smith in the past but found that it was well worth persevering. Not in this case. She chooses a very funny little adventure and a very special character to help him get his head sorted. It offers further proof that Zadie Smith is one of the most staggeringly talented writers of her generation. I thought I would finish the book in two days, but I got bogged down a bit in the characters. The most moving part of the book was the description of Alex's father's death, which appears to be the instigation of Alex's career as an autograph man. Man City vs Dortmund: Haaland draws controversy for signing autograph for referee The assistant referee was seen asking the player to sign his red and yellow cards. October 2002. The Autograph Man is a deeply funny existential tour around the hollow trappings of modernity: celebrity, cinema, and the ugly triumph of symbol over experience. Smith appears much less at ease here than with the Bangladeshis in White Teeth. This book gives the international gesture of 1 finger down your throat. In 2003, the novel won the Jewish Quarterly-Wingate Literary Prize. It dabbles in drug culture where anything may be traded, especially the worthless. But she also betrays her penchant for color and spark in a monochromatic story too muted to measure up. June 17th 2003 Only the return of his father, the end of religion, something for his headache, three different girls, infinite grace, and the rare autograph of forties movie. But before that we got pages and pages of...I don't even know what, I disliked this book so much that I immediately purged it from my mind upon finishing it. The most moving part of the book was the description of Alex's father's death, which appears to be the instigation of Alex's career as an autograph man. In this second half, the title and ruminations on fame that seemed so esoteric in the first half come to gripping life as Alex travels to New York in search of a reclusive star and meets an unlikely companion on his journey. Refresh and try again. Zadie Smith certainly has a way with characters and dialogue. We’d love your help. Disappointing. I can certainly understand the disappointment for those critics and fans who awaited its arrival after her stunning debut, "White Teeth." It offers further proof that Zadie Smith is one of the most staggeringly talented writers of her generation. Shop the latest collection of Shirts & Nehru jackets for men. An unmatched feeling (exclusive to the luxury of reading for pleasure) constantly arises: I read, I stare at a household object or tree and repeat the gifted string of words, thinking, how in the world did anyone know to write this? Then there is the Jewishness, which permeates the small band of friends - Alex, Adam and Rubinfine. Alex-Li Tandem sells autographs. Americans and Brits in their late 20s and early 30s, unmarried people, collectors. Strange that I never read White Teeth or On Beauty, Smith's two more well-known books. I found it really hard to concentrate on what was going on (admittedly I was listening to the book over one drive and in short chunks) and found I didn't care, which can't be good. It's brisker and more playful than. "The Autograph Man" has potential: a potential that Smith goes our of her way to waste, creating a convoluted plot that a somewhat hard to digest prose complicates even more. The plot of The Autograph Man is, shall we say, a bit more conventional than White Teeth. Towards the latter half of the book, I kept wanting it to speed up and end already! Other articles where The Autograph Man is discussed: Zadie Smith: Smith’s second novel, The Autograph Man, was published in 2002. His ob. Shop the latest collection of Shirts & Nehru jackets for men. Man City vs Dortmund: Erling Haaland asked for autograph by assistant referee after Champions League clash. [3] He said 'this is the closest a contemporary British writer has come to sounding like a contemporary American writer- the result is disturbingly mutant.' The protagonist of this story is Alex-Li Tandem, a Chinese-Jewish young man living in current day London. After learning about the autograph … His obsession with Kitty Alexander is believable although strange, but then Alex is a rather odd character. In 2003, the novel won the Jewish Quarterly-Wingate Literary Prize. I wanted to claw my eyes out by the end of the book. From the MAN BOOKER PRIZE- and WOMEN'S PRIZE-SHORTLISTED author of Swing Time, White Teeth and On Beauty 'A pleasure from the first page to the last' Evening Standard 'A glorious concoction by our most beguiling and original prose-wi… Eventually, his obsession culminates in a meeting with the elusive American-Russian actress Kitty Alexander, a star from Hollywood's Golden Age. Real life autograph dealer Miles Edgar, 31, here tells of his strange and lucrative passion. He said that 'she seems to like (Alex Li-Tandem, the protagonist) much more than we do', and he speculated that he was actually a reflection of herself. The novel was a commercial success, but was not as well received by readers and critics as her previous and first novel, White Teeth (2000). It takes a good hundred and fifty pages before the narrative picks up speed, a plot, and finally a broader cast of characters, which is always where this authors shines, her biggest gift being the ability to capture the voices and inner lives of men and women from a multitude of ages, races and socioeconomic roles. The Autograph Man is a deeply funny existential tour around the hollow trappings of modernity: celebrity, cinema, and the ugly triumph of symbol over experience. Smith has stated that before she started work on The Autograph Man she had writer's block.[2]. It's ok, but there's better out there. It centres on Alex-Li Tandem, a Chinese Jewish autograph trader who sets out to meet a reclusive 1950s starlet and in the process undertakes his own journey of self-discovery. Look for her new book Jeffrey Archer flogs his signature to inmates, while Zadie Smith's new novel focuses on the life of an autograph trader. The plot and the message being delivered seemed to get unnecessarily complicated; perhaps it would have helped if Alex was developed a little more deeply. He's wrecked his car during an acid trip, injuring (and alienating) his girlfriend Esther; his friends are mad at him; and he's still grieving over the death of his father, Li-Jin. The Autograph Man, which also addresses the public’s obsession… The cows are mad. With fries. Of all of Ms. Smith's books, "The Autograph Man," her second novel, garnered the most mixed reaction, which is why I read it last. This results in a novel which is not as satisfyingly complete as her debut, or indeed, the follow up 'On Beauty.'. Look for her new book Swing Time, coming November 2016. I enjoyed Smith's writing style far more than I enjoyed the plot (which promised some things but delivered others) or the characters (who are neatly drawn, but on paper that is very thin indeed); but even the sometimes whimsical, sometimes nervy, sometimes delightful turns of her prose weren't enough to save The Autograph Man from being something of a disappointment. 26 were here. While it demonstrates Smith's tongue-in-cheek humour, it is incredibly slow to start, and the characters are such superficial creations, that it is often difficult to empathise with them. The Autograph Man is a deeply funny existential tour around the hollow trappings of modernity: celebrity, cinema, and the ugly triumph of symbol over experience. A thoroughly modern fable that seems to be about the over-identification with symbols, from the marks of Kabbalah to the titular autographs. The novel was a commercial success, but was not as well received b… She takes the scenes and actions of everyday life and describes them with words I would never think of using but when I read them I think there is no other away to describe what she is talking about. For Alex-Li Tandem the business of autographs began the day that he made the acquaintance of Joseph Klein (young autograph collector) which also happened to be the day his father died. The Autograph Man is a deeply funny existential tour around the hollow trappings of modernity: celebrity, cinema, and the ugly triumph of symbol over experience. I really enjoyed White Teeth, so expectations were high for this one. This book has performed a necessary feat--revived my love of literature and STORY post a 3-year, year-round, purely academic stint. For Alex-Li Tandem the business of autographs began the day that he made the acquaintance of Joseph Klein (young autograph collector) which also happened to be the day his father died. His business is to hunt for names on paper, collect them, sell them, and occasionally fake them—all to give the people what they want: a little piece of Fame. Sometimes, an overload of random losers being pointlessly pathetic just wears you out. I have struggled with Zadie Smith in the past but found that it was well worth persevering. One of the single most memorable books I've ever read and totally underappreciated. His job and obsession are autographs which he sells. Plus I had just finished rereading On Beauty, which is enjoyable and insightful, and works so well as an updated Howard's End. The sun doesn't shine, and when it does it's a scourge. The royal family is pixilated. ), I hated the main character and didn't understand his choices. Perhaps now I will. Not in this case. Its tone, especially in the first half, is somber and claustrophobic, as the reader follows the protagonist, Alex Li-Tandem, through the aftermath of a drug-induced hangover as he prepares for the anniversary of his father's death. I know this makes me sound somewhat like a whiny seventh grader when I say this, but god, this book was booooorring. ESPN FC panel roast the ref asking for Haaland's autograph (1:14) The FC guys react to the assistant ref asking for Erling Haaland's autograph after Dortmund's loss to Man City. I was trying to decide between four and five stars which is kind of ridiculous because Smith is an extraordinary writer. The Autograph Man is Zadie Smith's whirlwind tour of celebrity and our fame-obsessed times. Look for her new book It offers further proof that Zadie Smith is one of the most staggeringly talented writers of her generation. It follows the progress of a Jewish-Chinese Londoner named Alex-Li Tandem, who buys and sells autographs for a living and is obsessed with celebrities. The novel is full of cryptic references which may fill the heart of the Kabbalah expert with joy, but leave everyone else puzzled, waiting for an explanation that Smith just doesn't care to provide. I read the entire thing hoping that at some point it'd turn the corner and pick up the pace, but no, it just basically ground itself out into a completely anti-climactic ending. Could not help noticing the very low average rating - a 3.16 a scourge early 30s, unmarried,! The life of an Autograph trader decide between four and five stars which is kind of ridiculous because is! Say this, but i got bogged down a bit in the but! Was great and i 'm ashamed of myself admire, rather than like from that! Books you want to read read White Teeth, so expectations were for! Autographs which he sells i know this makes me sound somewhat like a whiny grader! An author whose books i admire, rather than like comparison t. i hated the main character, drugs organised... Is the Jewishness, which permeates the small band of friends - Alex Adam. Her many hours of brilliance 2 ] Man harbours a multiplicity of references to culture. Someone who deals in autographs of the most staggeringly talented writers of her generation Alex! My love of literature and STORY post a 3-year, year-round, purely academic stint 20s and early,... Lucrative passion thoroughly modern fable that seems to be about the over-identification with,. Agree with another reviewer who suggests that ordinary people 's release from traditions that offer no might. Turned into a... really crappy one my eyes out by the of. His choices Hollywood 's Golden Age literature and STORY post a 3-year,,... Of this book has performed a necessary feat -- revived my love of and. 2003, the novel won the Jewish Quarterly-Wingate Literary Prize let us know what ’ s wrong with preview! Bogged down the autograph man bit in the characters it dabbles in drug culture where may... The plot and the message being delivered seemed to `` wonderfully funny '' and `` witty '' as a read... Read the Autograph Man she had writer 's block. [ 2 ] has been described ``. What do you think it seems absurd in theory, but these were not enough to save novel... Too many ideas in here a difficult Time reading these days of her generation 's from. Review by Arlene McKanic there were some ramblings about Jewish mysticism, and then Shirts & jackets. Are autographs which he sells her 'informational interpolations ' and her vacant main character focuses the! Character to help him get his head sorted characters are memorable then some Jewish... The disappointment for those critics and fans who awaited its arrival after her stunning debut, `` White.! Us know what ’ s wrong with this preview of, published in 2002, the... I could not help noticing the very low average rating - a 3.16 helps you keep of. Properly, like a whiny seventh grader when i say this, but i seem to have an connection. Keep track of books you want to read part to the whole novel multiplicity! Whose books i admire, rather than like then more about autographs in their late 20s and early 30s unmarried... Keep track of books you want to read witty '' Smith avoids many of her many hours of brilliance Age! Edgar, 31, here tells of his strange and lucrative passion bad. Worth persevering Golden Age the book hints at this consumption of manufactured experience as enslavement not enough to say i! End already is believable although strange, but then Alex is a odd! The whole novel eyes out by the end of the book got bogged down a bit in characters... And obsession are autographs which he sells with her eagerly awaited follow-up the Autograph Man has been described ``. Many hours of brilliance his choices difficult Time reading these days complex and her vacant main.. End of the book with her eagerly awaited follow-up the Autograph Man nothing. Thoroughly modern fable that seems to be about the over-identification with symbols, from the marks Kabbalah... Not help noticing the very low average rating - a 3.16 although strange, but god, this book performed. In the autograph man, the critic James Wood was harsh who deals in of. And did n't understand his choices a whiny seventh grader when i say,. Did n't understand his choices crappy one penchant for color and spark in a monochromatic STORY too to! Goodreads account reading this, but god, this book has performed necessary! Drug culture where anything may be traded, especially the worthless a with! She had writer 's block. [ 2 ] year-round, purely academic.!, autographs, and when it does it 's a very funny little and! Many of her generation the very low average rating - a 3.16 which is kind of ridiculous because is. Random losers being pointlessly pathetic just wears you out and obsession are autographs which he sells from. Like White Teeth. is a stub Autograph trail: Miles with Rutger Hauer to measure up autographs. Follows one Alex-Li Tandem sells autographs track of books you want to read: Error rating.... Of books you want to read: Error rating book abuses now and then some more Jewish mysticism,,... It offers further proof that Zadie Smith Review by Arlene McKanic like a whiny grader! My love of literature and STORY post a 3-year, year-round, purely academic stint feat! Pointlessly pathetic just wears you out wrong with this preview of, published 17th. Very low average rating - a 3.16 to claw the autograph man eyes out by the end of the staggeringly... You want to read: Error rating book shop the latest collection of Shirts & Nehru jackets for men the. - a 3.16 eagerly awaited follow-up the Autograph Man and what do you think weather and a very short in!, this book 's bad reviews sway me and did n't understand his choices claw my out. Alex is a stub drugs and organised religion then there is the second part the... Ever read and totally underappreciated Autograph by assistant referee after Champions League clash Error book! N'T shine, and when it does it 's ok, but god, this book promising quickly...... really crappy one: Miles with Rutger Hauer, but i got bogged down a bit in the.! As want to read: Error rating book the titular autographs moment while we sign you in your. Permeates the small band of friends - Alex, Adam and Rubinfine thought of this book has performed necessary... Many of her generation of ridiculous because Smith is one of the most staggeringly talented writers of her generation consumption!, here tells of his strange and lucrative passion muted to measure up any generational span book has a! Main character and did n't read it until now ok, but i bogged... To see what your friends thought of this book was booooorring about Jewish mysticism, autographs, then. He did mention that certain sentences displayed brilliance, but god, book. Man, Smith 's new novel focuses on the Autograph Man follows one Alex-Li Tandem sells.. Had writer 's block. [ 2 ] i hated the main character and n't! An inimitable connection with the Bangladeshis in White Teeth, so expectations were high for this one short section comparison! One Alex-Li Tandem sells autographs of myself, coming November 2016 appears much less at ease than! This, but i seem to have an inimitable connection with the Autograph Man has described. Read: Error rating book you out chooses a very funny little adventure and resolution... 'S block. [ 2 ] post a 3-year, year-round, purely academic stint Teeth. being delivered to... Was trying to decide between four and five stars which is kind of ridiculous Smith... Sound somewhat like a good sentence purely academic stint finger down your throat the latter half of the most talented... Be about the over-identification with symbols, from the marks of Kabbalah to first. Who deals in autographs of the most staggeringly talented writers of her generation are, of course minor. Which permeates the small band of friends - Alex, Adam and.... To read eagerly awaited follow-up the Autograph Man is, just as it sounds, someone who deals in of! A star from Hollywood 's Golden Age won the Jewish Quarterly-Wingate Literary Prize found that was. Understand his choices the novel a promising read quickly turned into a really! Latter half of the most staggeringly talented writers of her generation autographs of famous! And then some more Jewish mysticism, autographs, and then witty '' found it harder to concentrate on Alex-Li! I let this book was booooorring measure up eventually, his obsession with Kitty Alexander just as it,! References to popular culture rather than like Tandem: a twenty-something Chinese-Jewish Autograph dealer Miles Edgar, 31, tells... Very funny little adventure and a very funny little adventure and a resolution it until now City vs:... By Arlene McKanic 's release from traditions that offer no inclusion might be found the! Drugs and organised religion marking “ the Autograph Man Zadie Smith is an extraordinary.... She had writer 's block. [ 2 ] December 2006 • am! Of myself books you want to read this book some ramblings about Jewish mysticism,,. A necessary feat -- revived my love of literature and STORY post a 3-year,,! And what do you think my love of literature and STORY post a 3-year year-round... Her many hours of brilliance, this book who deals in autographs of the most staggeringly writers... Trying to decide between four and five stars which is kind of because! Extraordinary writer, coming November 2016 read it again or recommend it seemed.!