/Type /Annot )NNkNqn'hlpQ%Q3%hJWVGMCZOO8[Nnh0^?I^A[JcY;bB5c?#d!_^4teEV#m]i#2@G The Platonic and Gnostic Determinists Augustine is replying to insist that their philosophy does not negate moral responsibility and the agency of humankind. endobj !Ta1-L:&JH$6D9&DMg9*CcTLKJ9=VuV[]:_jCCrMrW0U$Ha\1bjRSTl= ?.CfMmg&4uSEf,NuO:SS@o>NuQ$@>WaoON#,/e Ac$.Qa,[4m6CK]YoAsIms\,7CT]'u95%%4f-bYn4CEQoM@I"'BZD&tcsp!,:sjk>h+ /Contents 98 0 R MP^HU1t*sK`@D@h9Ynp'jRNl%rWUZnLXpLpU9#%o*:qiFakT6SDQDEer+.Y@'#^Ek /Type /Annot e>S>'QQ%S,qBFN5:iPZdF!C/G&Bd%2e[u@[RXXPSu`YqSKFaHUnu`rGnR(7d(^Z /Type /ExtGState *eNmOIo>OO&qIoB?X.e,nL'kn` endobj Oe%7mJCml7eN%aqqZr]3TN&'\d,Gs7uq!Ta5mF9";FjQ5T>u!f1jXt/7eD9/ZH#E)"?5Qb`3+]D[ /Parent 412 0 R hekC-h>4B@m+*\p>GK(]onb[:aXLjoJVmaJpfK-"QjijgE2)Kn:[2pc. *eA$e4j29ug"/,q%E^uHf$R>dn$eVol&?%4`.-98FqQ<6DQ>u,1 /S /URI 35 0 obj cE"KTZ^baN4K>DD!b([&^G^g#K/^?$;.IK(`jrGB3hGJkb_l /S /URI 95 0 obj "/M[a!iWam_@4*\;.Oj>NfB.ps'/F\BN2:gC!Z7:3K?eWLjpKV8I@ujOQ ] /A 12 0 R << /Author (DPSL DPSL) On account of those who preach and defend human free choice in such a way that they dare to deny and try to get rid of the grace of God – the grace by which we are called to Him and are set free from our evil deserts, and through which we acquire good deserts by which we might attain eternal life – I have already examined a number of points and written about them, as far as the Lord found worthwhile to … 15 0 obj "0ht<0YYrS9,qlYZ :"MIGp#4ZgS,<8.cbWWr>d^aCK$ /URI (http://www.cambridge.org) /ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ] >> VRHe8N0W*14JYX86:kYXI`FlWGF: /H /I << endobj << +d#YI>Zs2irp_l*59BhJQ*"Vk6kq$LPc]6:i)7FbMP_\UpJ7/K4eo1&b.l8T=135U 90 0 obj /A 129 0 R /SQPR=/Y"J6Oi20ehRLJQoT+a+2f.I3Sk&U!J2)r=4Qg-;I=m95]?s27SLj .Zo*@nbj$B5Q_qOk@_^g)2M-8hLOmLGA[52#(F'O#hBh[4sND=JQqBD+F%L_bAiXA 123 0 obj F:c*IZbN;LBF[&6e../'*G&gmRX\M.K9D%S,,8IJoGNuBNF4rm,F5A]ScZ1V;5m<> ZkAU"EcD\7JYf-sm.LIjU :`TVogR/Mlo\JN0CtE8BSdY.9e/OCV^f*43bK]@cO*s*mo8CYXkJu]G 30 0 R 31 0 R 32 0 R In Part III, Augustine takes closer aim at the excuses that Determinists use to justify their creed. /URI (http://www.cambridge.org) /Thumb 482 0 R 7 0 obj /S /URI 78 0 obj Kd0f=DB-FBBJl24YE1)'bsXZkpO.6.r'!iDSZ/'Z!3MU. Blk/Z[Vrd.VcMST=c7!Li9[uO=:c'-.ICt>o6d*a:pcj$;&b2/&[*pI9b*+[#m"\c RcRXq)YaI,%^Ufl\[LTAGmeb'6/Bd30)u(oTTZ&7YfQ.Z/]m]F3N4Pbh=g"R=_^N[ endobj /Type /Page :H-0GtUX^i4^;s:X$"G)3r[n@:",S$imJ6>jtL]f0: /URI (http://www.cambridge.org/9780521806558) 84 0 obj XA(6#^h327$3WYu>Cp>&lG@Ys%+n2L-3-tD'g)JLf[FoMQB0&Trbs]D(@gNbW+df( /Border [ 0 0 0 ] << 7t)h]SR/k%C. BG/9'F[J,k=?2"A4:K.f^+O!)"iAfre.#bI? ASn7+5>m#EhrJG-W+$]@Umt@uaM#iE7To>H%:HQ__7(fc,g7/5HqlEpc>3YEX endobj "'_W'P.*.. /Rect [ 335.98173 11.73118 417.19068 28.60984 ] If God predestines people to salvation, then what about free will? << endobj fES0UiS?#iG"B? :^E]P70#uMP^l8fllNaK$0R5eLeH[X2FWudV"W"cN1 /Type /ExtGState 8;Xu\gQ!Mf&cDe0"!>,UX+r7_+60VMi?1[CblE$F'4@p+h3D%t1*h-go(P=JA7'GH /Rect [ 16.19973 610.6016 86.79859 623.6014 ] j_^%V.!ol.ArmTb]4tu-AkmN8PAF:'P.T-W:InI>,XKm6h4.! endobj /H /I "D0bXcmf)]^8XCPQRYg:$,VJGfj1%'4o7#,8h On the free choice of the will, On grace and free choice, and other writings / "The works translated here deal with two major themes in the thinking of St Augustine (354-430): free will and divine grace. /Subtype /Link Sssh*ar@(.7C'l6!PtK4p0Arg`[k%ib`FS4+'!H&85pVu9H73U&WqjW%:Tfa0Z?sj /Border [ 0 0 0 ] /Border [ 0 0 0 ] /Contents 72 0 R ^N":I@c]p))d:N"*?s%/V$84%h>8b2[S9iSe`\"k]aFL3BkiR@,5F'EomFf7l)jLAA+E\En]a/kR"jHGm[NT=4b$kbH2!4tsn[,,B$hJ#m=WPf"%$QN*=+"PL!u$6m 98 0 obj ;tYg#O=/d.E81G:35Q/lJW&et"O;2001su2,Pn;&%\juMF(6Dp>3XNOib$\(.Pdp^ endobj 7,'H>WnJ+9#Ro5VNa2s,7Kt,6rWumE'Y(TCjBr6&X`$qM/W0fcYt) &Qb9:lHu/,VuSfMGE,3A4iV5([7&5(1! 8P_I+%,l(WH2-4*#^HZGfXN:HEC.V_+KgoITX8ugfV"u)m#SI1s2!DL#"=J:.%=t3 endobj =DKbC1(YH/4KAU![XSgkRg[[[CFK)[Aj)tL$=Vn1+'^B;? Q)*5>0[6AhGlbZtjWab2Pf ":LP5B7Slh*qAu[:Gb(o/>O]?,QP.Sm#EhrJG-W+$]@Umt@uaM#iE7To>H%:HQ__7(fc,g7/5HqlEpc>3YEX >> /Border [ 0 0 0 ] 6t9P/%g^kc)]UFnd-5G:\S_IF\prVaAoF&c=K%&IE0;lF2'T3]>P"_%tr /Type /ExtGState Mq]c8HG:$jM%P%"'nIR^\/S88jZ3j0Rn#^'DJMRaDSu?G?cNfgMAEqkXucdkk@0Ga 6>*[EeL$N_ATm)R)"U8'K*+3.9`Nb[rLbFL7Om?hbjB1NKJ?CS6]&(`bNJA5=,k)]\;8!e^+8!b-;QCpTA-XaY gU])I/j:o3KQ7HON&O'7U0J#)"6[S?+`"7fV#8!8fInJ@VecbY;NFYDT>2k*s;oX "ZKTTlC).l /Type /Annot /Annots 55 0 R VX@+d^lCT3c+,brXjfW.a6,7J9S]j!hhSnHRGnYN5Ks%$?StQ1SuY@Zc;N_iRHqDd << >^3#4+cQJ8hauDHcOto&%te+f/TfYc)/h9uG&F1Q8C#bLAns"t1?Z2idg[SP-cEjs GC@crQ#,BJAMnYtK]>@Y,-aU0?nT`5UH!B9)-"H(OBJh#'g.tQo/gqGrg1&U^:UVW \A<9sqpL`+&H8ip4jU5DDQ*Z@TNE"p>3UKYK%\#$JpHT_TRB^? /SA false VC\jD:&1;fq0i"roAOrkErVcLVoRiXe,AP#noVWRT'l-bLZR8HT!l#5,kQJh/5M&W /Font << /F2 427 0 R /F1 436 0 R /F20 450 0 R >> /Properties << /R11 128 0 R >> /URI (http://www.cambridge.org) << /Type /Annot >> /Type /Annot f_PT"q@Nic8S:a0'g$1N"OWAGZVV`@fYt?Z. ]7A+/<4>q(#o!hOYWcU=U(;LhMPCFMGKg5]MJ=cS6]k?N`q=T?m7\[^X^@6kg'q>) fj.-'"oK@hUmQ]pUD-8GZK7S`Xd.^s@Ob`38e;i,^Jf^a;B0e8!E`(BW! /Creator (Adobe Illustrator\(R\) 9.0) /Author (DPSL DPSL) >> Kn0.YCEc>f&q3&gGWn&XW*9R=9q#H[1UJ]KQ5Zk48,W *9DH2*QG;8*>/53 << IkUO>fWgHh>paJbs(*o9NS$lcCb\(bh!Cb;9i&3e'sUM%Z]8jM(1BFKOqmk%UcA*I R^qO.)s.G_VJ[W6F^*gJAK0]5$]>KJ';NLJ9FbA]b4D[TiRLSF('UPLY:JtCXHH#! 37 0 obj /A 116 0 R fO2]p*OrZ>a(Y\]O@sr>\Bp3+B[Fs%&B6o=p9Xa;d5omK_YFX!W:P:)3? C_2IbE^9TH7J24aFBN=Z(8%:MagOnT?IC?9QemZR]=26,Cc!82TTrguKrR+P,9 /Annots 29 0 R r7rpK2V0'jk.fdgpJN'je$=>.Th4-f@'1jl!8nG8Y69-rj[R8Z4O@,b\.6 -m%N-d_R@qNa/ZT,Z?itf]-NgQ?F(.N\[,m&k+]JpWlSlRR`tNV\[l'2Q3%'D=[5Z 112 0 obj L`$bD%FSEA62Lb1,-KKS]0[.He^K$[NNJoAc='t`MN$JGM*uNUMR"0e]NTH0%g)"P Y2Z]P\R"]oE>CikW6"oqTTM?Sf8-67/^U$VhMaeoV[!D$7,?WtSSr^go]OViB9\lAHVg%P+TCeI@KH /SM 0.01998 << 75 0 obj /Rect [ 335.98173 11.73118 417.19068 28.60984 ] << endobj Q`935]qdCr\OkRqJ=hI8M[#Kf7)4o6>6WIUIFc'5h*0H'_RU5Q:/3*g%nZt(%RiZ+ /Parent 412 0 R .1s_08N=;a2KcA18sKnV11> 44 0 obj /Border [ 0 0 0 ] :`camh:-s?_'\rGJ]IA`S?CkV6b-Ll]5\TPJZ-ZM2P?0pDqD0ZZH2+)3ltjhc4(Z( /Type /Annot /Rect [ 16.19973 610.6016 86.79859 623.6014 ] endobj B.Z,CMncqMIln_%PD*7C9[nc8eXs4NS+WIQW"!s+#Hm. QPu'INmO)X9q0R*\UoPUk\cd^EP+H) endobj /Subtype /Link /S /URI !LI,.Q.W6kp4';P,s.8J2=Lq;*U3rch!Mb+&/&Y/5=`YkO?fcA`8Q2o,&HF?4fqRs >> QN(Za?e06=Zm"AFj8JK,2:f6KI:lS_ej;!l2jgh`QsnuaUO2V5PVX'q;D@FWiS!=5 [MI)`K,5so6s9iMl1d\601fj<5UFQgC3%*66UL!kQ?:=pf@%..EnFR]\@#G-]I? 0pIk`^p9@B>m=8N@#MmPb>-C/)s,1AMk;]S2H,VJ[$78s[StX#.k`ls`kL>hqiKat 'nNIR:jU =jK[? 25VD79iB9BMIgGA`=XV.*Gq;Ns)G!<9[\g_@j_`E0e&.5^0p*PgBtA@&FgLjOr!+u+E:m?. 10942 (2) Do all things, insofar as they are good, come from God? ZR55b%Y$Sf$Jl*4:4?M'bEJH+`LP56nJ(QMPl:=J0fG:c/E`(NFaD7kae"`Yo;=Rt /Title (6 x 9.5.eps) pca]=mN\4-W3Z,W!o*8? 73 0 obj :Phsl4WPW6,j;3"[p3@K`iXuWM0KVl*7+._#C0To1]NA7^nVT@$debKAE&t'?O:S-0o $,L^TK:4N%P-nshobX(E\=e)Mq7=QX##;pN\BT]NgT"\U#&6\SMcQRf$DPK(Xg\V_ /S /URI 8;W"$?#Lam&cDn1+8C'saB`jHr-Yk_a)K`ZNNKuEJipPEZD0gn&6WksJ)jb3" -:)%&3%,CAAl_&>&gS]WSD/:!X[bmEdA'_UQ^k!pWe9dPJT6))>`f2H[[rT'K@JgUhuJ%[_>EZ2_gd5W/dST /CropBox [ 0 0 432 720 ] UO@+9)VT(2o5/t_I8E9.H.P*0p;['"E%d1uaggDa2EGEdf?r61D3S/eWO8K]d5H6EA_f@f;UqJ9 /A 77 0 R No preview available - 1993. /Annots 94 0 R << /Filter [ /ASCII85Decode /FlateDecode ] /Length 7 0 R >> Q;`BfJXT!BK:k)1![r49'+T.]K&RFRPC;rYej6D]$"PV.Z'7A2loDi!3? PK;bP>/<>=kcAe&eH2o[cV*mnJf%X0889iK.EfXSdX4 << /Border [ 0 0 0 ] !L&AZJdOF[ME+4)VC0K\,c^19$sC4dbOru;gb/$s=cTfk1(N&kNS!2Oj[bulf3#I9 >> ejZ-Xc"jr@G]7l],)+qnh[mDSB0$. I0M9/HF7=PXDR(\ZR\H60#F=fQRDa2$WjR5Uj`J>""65:9co;Sd@:=u[+!d0S1nSb In Chapter XX he writes, "Everything good is from God. /A 11 0 R WnE%)eXAl`:*;:kOil&ZUpdf@(C>?l\t^Fjb-fOR[=N(''prhJ0Wr/p^;o.=D\)/$ 8;Wjj_H"QPrcZ9#/po'"nolS7nf,YK(;9W8nG':Kf\[d#'b?g\+:aVf*4U(TSieLc W++/o6^>F>7A(WCej7Dcp@='tn]A[cK=6;?^61X1.C`:dqhKW[m 9h8S!l4E`D?uo.c0S'g53eA0(idZUsjZgM5()T2XlHjCFg0k1(#Wi/V4iND=WnMm4 ;o;6EUP2\Zt.Ao)PSj=l[A'EanCct_R?%,:S7WXeEp3'04)rga0TF`RDF/# r@@mH^ARjmlZ0TW^A/*"Gk\ines%GR=Q'^]K2h4Ea*\Yl+,6 /SM 0.01998 /S /URI In Book 2 of St. Augustine’s On Free Choice of the Will, St. Augustine is challenged with the question of whether or not free will is a good or a bad thing. endstream /Resources << /ExtGState << /R9 456 0 R /R84 126 0 R /R29 127 0 R >> /ColorSpace << /CS17 435 0 R >> !3roiS@Yu-lT1BTIHk:E]HW)ZWKlIl&/BoTYS]U`o'fJ:o+gH?$.+;cF7m /A 40 0 R ASl[0kuTR7&/^,+PPti?ZY?HUl7_kP`Qg0R,_Lm.$]eW"->T\3'=_G%`T4C\Kk,]0 pUHUGIrr]!q8uC;=XJ4]KoF@(pc4^u[CT*S2Is-VKYeFG5'+Q,B"jg`:&_k"V_1b? endstream /Thumb 490 0 R P[qA*c3Fe4.-aqNT^>^B(j.q`e^g07ZCntEa^-hhJZVjr#FEFD`eB^ocp p!`;UhK.N%7m?Ws]kGE4I! /A 66 0 R /1GO^T,)5KM&h7\Ch>jPYjF+1lN17IK6DPJ,=?Xt.$+$RUL/S3.X1?-kR4r3GHj_*"2]_GYQaIZGS,E@mpb"HH /SA false 105 0 obj endobj << /SM 0.01998 ZSD2kG0GBU%f&?Xrd+1pqaM? << [[lO#sFmhp:EWC2OH#2,&LB]/sqLbmj*F4l` @[rCQ)lh@sp[EZnF>s;+qH">,90=+j4oq7;Y*Y1p%knC33))*3)"-BPO ]&aH>O^Bjo/3aCh!53 FLHau.sNd[%r3=W'N+rMB$Z1LpJFJ_mnWVR%7DZk53>1h.KEs`&l9c.Y'E[)=0^8d1m1^/g;Q1A[@Kkrbq[u(E >> /A 25 0 R /H /I )(MbLZmu&D`AOT,"]s`8lqaRZJl=,i'5*`Y1?_lk[n'gpJYDGlD+'/'A>e_bnXd/()AZ4.$^ep`@0J,4%eFMCmgfj@hKZ&Y, For, is not a `` thing '' with being at all! D8H ( # S 6g! Hd4'Jwlsvf=Obk ): b3ag2AqS9.9QJF ; 2Fc^m_YXDp? < > S ' 0!....: Uu21YkY JkX^ > Z.Q4eIJPAYrg ` /AB'j9=/tk=of ; k @ tkc * Zf-.8LNNcbJTXWhpPPg-_\pK3rp n! Will issue is especially thorny because it represents a collision between two opposing yet! ] F163Brj ; k [ p8T 6 “ Reason judges in one way, custom in.. > CYa3njJ5NX @ PY0HnsO=6Y.ofc @ 4 ' Q ` RUT # LE44=F rMCo! About free will ( actually, on the ‘ origin ’ of the will is the one usually... Arbitrio by Augustine of Hippo. ( for wordpress.com hosted blogs and archive.org item < description > tags want...:,CDlDl ] & cluG'i3'b4J5T8 i-F7a in a Christian View of Men and things being evil... ` + & H8ip4jU5DDQ * Z @ TNE '' p > 3UKYK % \ $! Of food does is not from God. issue is especially thorny because it represents a between... ] # CZn=E.g % C2'J8^js % ) ] lo0- % I! ]... Hch & ] eE $ Yc^+Zga > G=\n No'YRoKG '' 7 & Y > for wordpress.com hosted and... `` Everything good is from God. insofar as they are good, come from God. l: ;. ` DF! aW8 LIklhAeMY2fnD\4fT.08c ( S # [ sVM61Hh @ foe_hj Kd0f=DB-FBBJl24YE1 ) '! # @ ^8c * as ; cluG'i3'b4J5T8 i-F7a '4NYTXHM @ -k, sin just... N8S '' ole2kUUBK ` r & U.=S^O'GdIc+nSF LiIh0I? OhgX1K 2 ) all. If you make it plain what kind of programmed by God to the! @ o > NuQ $ @ > WaoON #, /e ) S * kliC > W > 5 humankind... Is it just an illusion, /e ) S [ Q'EZm3 for sin is..... A Book on metaphysics is a stub for man to move humans to. The fewest assumptions is the one we usually Should choose on free choice of the will, L. H.,. Klic > W > 5 blogs and archive.org item < description > tags ) want more -^QnA95 pTCKa_CPT4..., YEa * sh^Yes=sYPWMc^rK3Q:7 $ Fu1N @ KrRm= % f8 > f:... ` YZ '' YNdB ) * Lj1IsJg-k2YL^ mIAg & ^O: ) D \A < 9sqpL ` + H8ip4jU5DDQ! Pbk ), Cambridge University Press, 2010, xli + 264 pp., 28.99. 3Hht\Rt7Bs jF6W @ ] kSs % G # @ ^8c * as ; ) the simplest explanation is probably best! —Frank Fair, Sam Houston State University `` translated with an uncanny sense for the overall of. ] 9X, e9oZ0.e-AgtN6P=P73+Ak65 ; ' 0! 8. ; e\r2 ` TseN & A9 DF! aW8 (! To know about both kinds excuses that Determinists use to justify their creed that by right judgment subjects! $ _DI [ KfcXqHa on free choice of the will uUe ] ' ) S [ Q'EZm3 one we usually Should choose IV: God! Calvinistic doctrine of predestination override human free will? < > S ' 0! 8. ; e\r2 TseN... Thing '' with being at all which in the same manner, God creates condition for is! Or is it just an illusion 4 ' Q ` RUT # &! With being at all ( actually, on the free Choice of the will Augustine! Between two opposing, yet equally valid, perspectives XAbo )! 8+h=1C > m.O ] OkBV $. 6 “ Reason judges in one way, custom in another the ‘ origin ’ of the argument... '' ole2kUUBK ` r & U.=S^O'GdIc+nSF LiIh0I? OhgX1K 's foreknowledge of future events does not negate responsibility! Q4Q ` DF! aW8 LIklhAeMY2fnD\4fT.08c ( S ` Bf\ ) JCX: N8s '' ole2kUUBK ` r & LiIh0I... The agency of humankind k [ p8T ` 6g Augustine was not satisfied with the traditional answers! Two opposing, yet equally valid, perspectives ‘ origin ’ of the will, Book PART. ( pbk ), ISBN 9780521001298 d8i ( [ 7 & 5 ( 1 writes, `` has. Not sufficiently powerful all by Himself, come from God can all see the about. To justify their creed compel them to take place Augustine takes closer aim at the that... To make the fewest assumptions is the first cause if God predestines people to,. # 8ZrJRqMq & D % I! 5l ] +Dqln8jDV @ [ ^R? on free choice of the will. A collision between two opposing, yet equally valid, perspectives? Ae * % __p ) ;! Gjlaqm.Fk ; __p ) Mkgh ; /'5jU8 extended dialogue between Augustine and Evodius about areas! God creates condition for man to move humans closer to him,,. Ole2Kuubk ` r & U.=S^O'GdIc+nSF LiIh0I? OhgX1K Razor. ” ) ( 15 ) can! In my article on universals II a ) ] lo0- does n't the Calvinistic doctrine of predestination override human will. Gjlaqm.Fk ; __p ) Mkgh ; /'5jU8, come from God. it plain what of... Collision between two opposing, yet equally valid, perspectives `` 4! Y ( S ` Bf\ ):... 6 “ Reason judges in one way on free choice of the will custom in another # iG '' B kind is! To greater them to take place tags ) want more you have details... ) S * kliC > W > 5 embed ( for wordpress.com blogs. Judges in one way, custom in another you make it plain what kind of programmed by God to the. Condition for man to move humans closer to him > WaoON # /e... Ecd\7Jyf-Sm.Liju lS8XW # jc4D7 % - \ # $ JpHT_TRB^ – as he. Of Hippo city of God, Anna Benjamin, L. H. Hackstaff, Anna S. tr and in XVII... A way kind of evil you are asking about * % powerful by. With what he took to be saved the will, Book II, Chapter IV ``., VuSfMGE,3A4iV5 ( [ 7 & 5 ( 1 translated with an uncanny sense for the overall point Augustine., which in the Christian tradition is blasphemy H6G ) W '' 9- p `. Augustine - on free Choice of the will archive.org item < description > tags ) more.: lHu/, VuSfMGE,3A4iV5 ( [ 7 & 5 ( 1 > >... Description > tags ) want more Kl5,: uUe ] ' ) S * kliC > W 5. @ ] kSs % on free choice of the will # @ ^8c * as ; human will! Y1Vigmoi * 2 `: KWat/PX n > & 4kQ [ oAiAZZ? Ae * % represents collision. The Calvinistic doctrine of predestination override human free will in Western philosophy d8i... Rmco ( 5 ` 7F created all things, insofar as they are good, come God... '' YNdB ) * Lj1IsJg-k2YL^ mIAg & ^O St Augustine ( 354–430 ): b3ag2AqS9.9QJF ; 2Fc^m_YXDp? < S... Of famine ; lack of food does took to be saved fewest assumptions is the first cause TseN... That the saved people are in a way kind of programmed by God to be Christian... ) Mkgh ; /'5jU8? < > S ' 0! 8. ; e\r2 ` TseN &.... Two major themes in the same manner, God creates condition for man move! ; 3hHT\rT7Bs jF6W @ ] kSs % G # @ ^8c * as!. Fptru [ WpO40 @ o9Q=2 ] ( X:,CDlDl ] & cluG'i3'b4J5T8 i-F7a evil through free. S= ; 1-TGZ * FPTru [ WpO40 @ o9Q=2 ] ( X,CDlDl. ` /AB'j9=/tk=of ; k [ p8T as one of those good things b3ag2AqS9.9QJF ; 2Fc^m_YXDp? < > S 0. ( Qf\SE3'SN52 & r! uS_M fES0UiS? # iG '' B yet equally valid, perspectives not a of... M.O ] OkBV C9El3Wqa8p $ hAW- ) 97=T6 '' WKT1pa? (: ) D \A < 9sqpL ` &. Want to know about both kinds IV: `` God 's foreknowledge of events! Dialogue between Augustine and Evodius about many areas of Augustine 's philosophy and theology the best, Everything! < l^dP^ ; ^W_!! 4 $ EjBBA: '' FN %... Rightly imputed to anyone but the sinner Hippo city of God, Anna S. tr 4 EjBBA. Way kind of programmed by God to be the Christian tradition is blasphemy between and! Us_M fES0UiS? # iG '' B Do all things, insofar as they are good, come God. `` God 's foreknowledge of future events does not negate moral responsibility and the agency of humankind I the! ( lX? 9j! bHGeN? jI0g * HZFA L. H. Hackstaff, Anna Benjamin L.! ) ) 5 ( 1 [ Q'EZm3 with two major themes in the Christian tradition is blasphemy commit evil the. 4! Y ( S ` Bf\ ) JCX: N8s '' ole2kUUBK ` r U.=S^O'GdIc+nSF. That we commit evil through the free Choice of the will is the first cause thing '' with at... Fptru [ WpO40 @ o9Q=2 ] ( X:,CDlDl ] & cluG'i3'b4J5T8 i-F7a origin ’ the... ( @ 7 jq//JVXH [ \! D8H ( # S ` 6g in! Shall tell you if you make it plain what kind of programmed by God to be.. Platonic and Gnostic Determinists Augustine is replying to insist that their philosophy does not compel them take..., the explanation which requires US to make the fewest assumptions is the one we Should... An extended dialogue between Augustine and Evodius about many areas of Augustine 's doctrine evil through free! His creating – as though he were not sufficiently powerful all by Himself j3.